I would consider myself as more of a cook than a baker overall, but when a friend asks me to make her wedding cake of course I'm down for the challenge. How hard can an eight layer cake really be?!
Pretty hard actually, haha! Just kidding, it wasn't so bad. What made it easier was that the wonderful bride wanted a naked/rustic cake....for me that means imperfect is okay which is obviously very good because there wasn't a shot in hell I'd be reaching perfection on my first wedding cake (will strive for the second one though ;). Overall I was so proud of how it came out and have deemed myself open for cake making business! As long as you invite me to your wedding and let me drink endless wine and dance with old people.
Here she is, the monstrous final product:
At the end of the day I made 10 cakes. Two as test runs (which my family ate at my camp to ensure I was on the right track), and eight as final products. Overall, including frosting and assembling, the entire ordeal took about 15 hours not including shopping time. This blog post is by no means a post on how to make a wedding cake because I'm not an expert in that by any means..... yet ;) This is simply to share the Swedish Butter Cake recipe I used to make that cake because it was delicious and is perfect for not just weddings, but any celebration!
For the wedding I chose to add rum extract in the cake and serve with a mixed berry preserve and coconut Italian Meringue buttercream. When I baked the cakes as test runs, I served it with stawberries and whipped cream which everyone absolutely loved. My dad, who is a BIG frosting guy, said the cake was so good he'd even eat it without frosting... not sure if you realize how big of a cake compliment that is coming from him. Whatever you put on this cake, you'll be happy.

It is a recipe my boyfriend's aunt used to make for birthday cakes and it's in an old, wrinkled and stained cookbook (the best kind of cookbooks) that has been seriously well loved. The book states this cake is perfect for weddings because it is dense and easy to stack, with a classic flavor you can only get from a made-from-scratch cake that pairs well with any frosting. And it is SUPER moist and delicious, yet not overly sweet.... everything you would want from a wedding cake that will please any crowd. I had pre-wedding taste testers and approximately 70 people at the wedding who ate the cake, so I'm confident this recipe totally rocks.


My biggest concerns about the cake was the potential of it being lopsided, the frosting melting in the 85 degree weather and/or no one actually liking the cake/caring to eat it. Whether it was beginners luck or my years of obsession in the kitchen paid off, who knows, but the cake was as level and straight as I could have hoped for, the frosting held up surprisingly very well and the entire 8 layer beast was devoured. I received so many compliments and was really proud/aka relieved. Though the bride is very laid back and wouldn't have been too upset if I crashed and burned, (AWESOME human) I know how important a wedding cake is and I wanted to nail it for her. One of her relatives told me it was so good she couldn't believe it was my first wedding cake!
My big takeaways from this cake that I will most definitely carry on to the next one:
- Drink mimosas while building cake to ensure relaxation.
- Always bake a test cake so you aren't shitting yourself the entire time before the wedding wondering if the cake is good.
- Figure out how much batter needs to be in each layer to make them even in height... or just call it rustic when it comes out not 100% perfect.
- Start baking the cakes around 2 weeks before the wedding, wrap them in absurd amounts of saran wrap once they're completely cool and freeze until the day before the wedding then refrigerate.
- Bake only one cake layer at a time to ensure they bake evenly.... be patient young grasshopper.
- Have an assembling buddy to make life easier when you're putting it all together. Ideally one who feeds you booze.
- If possible, make the frosting the day of - mine changed consistency slightly after being refrigerated overnight, but luckily ended up stable and delicious.
- Dowels are necessary with the layer cake to hold it together. I used plastic ones and cut with a serrated knife but wood ones would work, too.
- Don't stress or panic because that's a waste of energy and everything will come out fine! Probably..
Big thanks to my sister Shauna for helping me assemble and decorate this bad boy. If you need an (affordable) and delicious tasting, rustic cake for a wedding or function, I am happy to be your girl!
<3333 Congrats to Emily and Derek!!!
Swedish Butter Cake -
from A Piece of Cake by Susan Purdy, 1989
Makes about 4 1/2 cups of batter - One 9 inch tube cake or one, two-layer 9 inch cake
Ingredients:
2 cups plus 2 tbsp flour
1 tsp baking powder
1/4 tsp salt
1 cup (2 sticks) butter, room temperature
1 1/2 cups sugar
2 large eggs, room temperature
3/4 cup milk
1 tsp vanilla/almond/rum extract (I actually used 1 tsp rum, 1/2 tsp vanilla)
Directions:
- (Tip - when measuring the flour, either measure out sifted flour or use a spoon to fill the measuring cup so you aren't packing in the flour to the cup)
- Preheat oven to 350 degrees and prepare your pans by greasing/buttering and dusting with flour.
- Use a whisk or sifter to mix together flour, baking powder and salt and set aside.
- Cream together butter and sugar until smooth and well blended. Add the eggs one at a time and beat after each addition.
- Add half the dry ingredients and mix until just combined then add the milk. Add remaining flour and mix until combined then stir in the flavor extract of your choice.
- Spoon the batter into prepared pan(s), level the top and spread the batter slightly to the pan edges. Bake in preheated oven until a toothpick comes out clean. This will be about 30 minutes for layers or up to 50-60 minutes for a tube cake. The top will be nice and golden.
- Cool the cake in the pan on a wire rack for about 10 minutes then remove from pan to cool completely on wire rack. Refrigerate/cool COMPLETELY before frosting or dusting with powdered sugar.
In case you aren't making an eight layer cake, here's a peak at my test recipe cake with strawberries and cream :)